Flex / Grid layouts not working on button or fieldset elements

ghz 1years ago ⋅ 10125 views

Question

I'm trying to center inner elements of a <button>-tag with flexbox's justify-content: center. But Safari does not center them. I can apply the same style to any other tags and it works as intended (see the <p>-tag). Only the button is left-aligned.

Try Firefox or Chrome and you can see the difference.

Is there any user agent style I have to overwrite? Or any other solution to this problem?

div {
  display: flex;
  flex-direction: column;
  width: 100%;
}
button, p {
  display: flex;
  flex-direction: row;
  justify-content: center;
}


<div>
  <button>
    <span>Test</span>
    <span>Test</span>
  </button>
  <p>
    <span>Test</span>
    <span>Test</span>
  </p>
</div>

And a jsfiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/z3sfwtn2/2/

Answer

The Problem

In some browsers the <button> element doesn't accept changes to its display value, beyond switching between block and inline-block. This means that a <button> element cannot be a flex or grid container, or a <table>, either.

In addition to <button> elements, you may find this constraint applying to <fieldset> and <legend> elements, as well.

See the bug reports below for more details.

Note: Although they cannot be flex containers,<button> elements can be flex items.

The Solution

There is a simple and easy cross-browser workaround to this problem:

Wrap the content of thebutton in a span, and make the span the flex container.

Adjusted HTML (wrapped button content in a span)

<div>
    <button>
        <span><!-- using a div also works but is not valid HTML -->
            <span>Test</span>
            <span>Test</span>
        </span>
    </button>
    <p>
        <span>Test</span>
        <span>Test</span>
    </p>
</div>

Adjusted CSS (targeted span)

button > span, p {
    display: flex;
    flex-direction: row;
    justify-content: center;
}

Revised Demo

References / Bug Reports

Flexbox on a <button> blockifies the contents but doesn't establish a flex formatting context

User (Oriol Brufau): The children of the<button> are blockified, as dictates the flexbox spec. However, the <button> seems to establish a block formatting context instead of a flex one.

User (Daniel Holbert): That is effectively what the HTML spec requires. Several HTML container-elements are "special" and effectively ignore their CSSdisplay value in Gecko [aside from whether it's inline-level vs. block- level]. <button> is one of these. <fieldset> & <legend> are as well.

Add support for display:flex/grid and columnset layout inside <button> elements

User (Daniel Holbert):

<button> is not implementable (by browsers) in pure CSS, so they are a bit of a black box, from the perspective of CSS. This means that they don't necessarily react in the same way that e.g. a <div> would.

This isn't specific to flexbox -- e.g. we don't render scrollbars if you putoverflow:scroll on a button, and we don't render it as a table if you put display:table on it.

Stepping back even further, this isn't specific to<button>. Consider <fieldset> and <table> which also have special rendering behavior.

And old-timey HTML elements like<button> and <table> and <fieldset> simply do not support custom display values, other than for the purposes of answering the very high-level question of "is this element block-level or inline-level", for flowing other content around the element.

Also see:

#html